Reports from the trenches of the San Diego beer scene

Beer & Sandals

San Diego is home to some of the finest beers, breweries and brewmasters in the world.

We relish the opportunity to be your companions in navigating these glorious waters.

Headless and Overpriced: Lost Abbey’s Angel’s Share

Posted April 27th, 2009 by Nate

I am so disappointed.

It’s not that I expect every beer to be perfect.  It’s not even that I expect every expensive beer to be perfect.  What I do expect is that if you brew, taste, and distribute a beer with a $30 price tag, it should be pretty damn good.  Unfortunately, this wasn’t the case with Angel’s Share.

My wife was kind enough to pick me up a bottle of this for Easter.  She went way out of her way to have a friend buy it for her and deliver it on the down-low so I’d be surprised.  It was a touching gesture, to be sure.  I decided I’d throw it in my cellar closet to let it age for a year before I tried it.

Imagine my surprise when I’m at BevMo the following week picking up supplies for a little get-together with friends and lo-and-behold, they are chock full of 2008 Angel’s Share.  I was delighted!  I could have a bottle to share with friends and one to age.

That night we crack the bottle after chilling it just a tad.  The nose on this beer was a little too reminiscent of Judgment Day, sweet and fruity in a raisin sort of way, but we still had high hopes. Initially the beer seemed flat so I really roughed up the pour and this thing just would not foam up.  Determined to power onward I let it breathe and warm up a bit before tasting it.

The taste is sour and the texture completely flat.  There is a mild hopiness to it, but not enough to salvage the rest.  This is just not a good beer.  We let it warm up a bit, thinking the alcohol would warm and bring out some different flavor: no dice.

Since drinking this beer and before writing this I looked around and found a lot of favorable reviews.  many of them mentioned the great head on this beer, which makes me think that Angel’s Share isn’t inherently bad, but there was just a bad batch.  This leads me back to my original point.  I’m still a huge fan of Lost Abbey.  They have some great beers (I’m looking at you, Devotion).  I am just sorely dissapointed that such a fine brewery would allow such a poor product to go to market.

Filed under:Uncategorized

1,152 Responses to “Headless and Overpriced: Lost Abbey’s Angel’s Share”